The Hierarchy of Controls Explained: How to Manage Hazards Effectively
Controlling hazards is the heart of occupational health and safety. But not all control measures are equally effective. That’s why safety professionals use the Hierarchy of Controls, a structured approach that prioritizes the most effective methods of reducing or eliminating hazards before resorting to less effective ones.
This guide breaks down each level of the hierarchy, provides real-world examples, explains how to apply it in your workplace, and ends with exam-oriented questions, detailed answers, and FAQs.
1. What is the Hierarchy of Controls?
The Hierarchy of Controls is a framework used to minimize or eliminate exposure to hazards. It ranks control methods from most effective to least effective:
- Elimination
- Substitution
- Engineering Controls
- Administrative Controls
- Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
This approach is endorsed by OSHA, NEBOSH, and ISO 45001 as a best practice for hazard management.
2. Why Use the Hierarchy of Controls?
- Effectiveness: Not all controls offer the same level of protection.
- Resource Allocation: Helps prioritize investment in the most effective measures.
- Compliance: Aligns with regulatory standards and audit expectations.
- Risk Reduction: Addresses hazards at their source instead of only protecting workers.
3. Levels of the Hierarchy of Controls
3.1 Elimination (Most Effective)
Definition: Completely remove the hazard from the workplace.
Examples:
- Design out a fall hazard by installing equipment at ground level instead of elevated.
- Automate a manual lifting task to remove manual handling hazards.
Key Point: If a hazard no longer exists, there’s no risk to manage.
3.2 Substitution
Definition: Replace a hazardous material or process with one that is less hazardous.
Examples:
- Use a water-based paint instead of a solvent-based one.
- Replace a noisy machine with a quieter model.
Key Point: Substitution reduces hazard severity or likelihood but requires evaluating new risks introduced by the substitute.
3.3 Engineering Controls
Definition: Isolate people from the hazard through physical means.
Examples:
- Machine guards and interlocks.
- Local exhaust ventilation for fumes.
- Soundproof enclosures around noisy equipment.
Key Point: Engineering controls act on the source or the path, not the worker.
3.4 Administrative Controls
Definition: Change the way people work.
Examples:
- Rotating staff to reduce exposure time.
- Training on safe work procedures.
- Safety signage and permits-to-work.
Key Point: Administrative controls rely on human behavior; they reduce but don’t eliminate hazards.
3.5 Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) (Least Effective)
Definition: Equipment worn by workers to reduce exposure.
Examples:
- Hard hats, safety goggles, gloves, respirators.
- Hearing protection in noisy environments.
Key Point: PPE is the last line of defense and only effective if selected, fitted, and maintained properly.
4. Applying the Hierarchy of Controls in Practice
- Identify Hazards: Use inspections, job safety analysis, and incident reports.
- Assess Risks: Evaluate likelihood and severity.
- Select Controls: Start at the top of the hierarchy and work downwards.
- Implement and Train: Install controls and train staff.
- Review and Improve: Monitor effectiveness and adjust as needed.
Example:
- Hazard: Chemical exposure during cleaning.
- Elimination: Use mechanical cleaning to remove the need for chemicals.
- Substitution: Switch to a less toxic chemical.
- Engineering: Install automated chemical dispensing systems.
- Administrative: Limit access, train staff.
- PPE: Provide gloves and respirators as backup.
For more on OSHA’s official recommendations for hazard control, visit OSHA’s Hazard Prevention and Control page — it provides detailed regulatory guidance on each level of the hierarchy.
5. Benefits and Limitations
- Benefits: Structured approach, regulatory alignment, proactive hazard control.
- Limitations: Some hazards can’t be eliminated or substituted; higher-level controls may be costly initially.
🎓 Exam-Oriented Questions with Detailed Answers
Short Answer Questions
Q1. List the five levels of the Hierarchy of Controls in order.
Answer: Elimination, Substitution, Engineering Controls, Administrative Controls, Personal Protective Equipment (PPE).
Q2. Why is elimination considered the most effective control measure?
Answer: Because removing the hazard completely means there is no potential for harm, eliminating the need for further controls.
Q3. Give two examples of engineering controls.
Answer: Installing machine guards to prevent contact with moving parts; using local exhaust ventilation to remove fumes at the source.
Long Answer Questions
Q1. Explain how substitution differs from elimination, with examples.
Answer: Elimination removes the hazard entirely, whereas substitution replaces it with something less hazardous. For example, eliminating a manual lifting task by automating it removes the hazard. Replacing a toxic solvent with a less toxic one is substitution—it reduces but does not eliminate the hazard.
Q2. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of administrative controls.
Answer: Administrative controls are easier and cheaper to implement but rely heavily on human behavior and compliance. They can reduce exposure time and improve safe practices but do not remove the hazard itself. For long-term effectiveness, they must be combined with higher-level controls.
Q3. Describe how the Hierarchy of Controls can be applied to control noise hazards in a factory.
Answer: Start by eliminating the noise source if possible (use silent processes). If not, substitute with quieter equipment. Install engineering controls like acoustic enclosures. Implement administrative controls such as rotating staff to limit exposure. As a last resort, provide hearing protection and conduct regular hearing tests.
Scenario-Based Questions
Q1. Workers are exposed to welding fumes. Apply the Hierarchy of Controls to manage this hazard.
Answer:
- Elimination: Use mechanical fastening instead of welding where possible.
- Substitution: Use low-fume welding rods or materials.
- Engineering Controls: Install local exhaust ventilation at welding stations.
- Administrative Controls: Limit time spent welding, rotate staff, provide training.
- PPE: Provide appropriate respirators and protective clothing.
Q2. A warehouse has frequent manual lifting injuries. How would you use the Hierarchy of Controls?
Answer:
- Elimination: Introduce automated conveyor systems to eliminate manual lifting.
- Substitution: Use lighter packaging materials.
- Engineering Controls: Provide mechanical lifting aids like hoists.
- Administrative Controls: Train staff on safe lifting techniques, implement job rotation.
- PPE: Provide back-support belts as a last resort.
Q3. Chemical spills are common in a laboratory. Apply the Hierarchy of Controls.
Answer:
- Elimination: Use processes that do not require the hazardous chemical.
- Substitution: Replace the chemical with a less hazardous one.
- Engineering Controls: Install spill containment systems and fume hoods.
- Administrative Controls: Implement strict chemical handling protocols, conduct drills.
- PPE: Provide chemical-resistant gloves, goggles, and lab coats.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the Hierarchy of Controls in simple terms?
Answer: It’s a ranked system for managing hazards, starting with the most effective (eliminate the hazard) and ending with the least effective (PPE).
2. Why is PPE considered the last line of defence?
Answer: Because it doesn’t remove or reduce the hazard itself—only protects the worker if an incident occurs. It’s also dependent on correct use and maintenance.
3. Can administrative controls be effective on their own?
Answer: They can reduce risk but are less reliable because they rely on people following procedures. They’re best combined with higher-level controls.
4. How often should the effectiveness of controls be reviewed?
Answer: Regularly—at least annually and whenever changes occur in equipment, processes, or after incidents.
5. Does the Hierarchy of Controls apply to all industries?
Answer: Yes, it’s a universal framework adaptable to any sector, from construction and manufacturing to healthcare and offices.
6. Is it mandatory to follow the Hierarchy of Controls?
Answer: While not always legally mandated word-for-word, regulators like OSHA and standards like ISO 45001 expect organisations to prioritise hazard elimination and higher-level controls before PPE.
6. Conclusion
The Hierarchy of Controls is more than a theoretical model—it’s a practical roadmap for managing hazards effectively. By starting at the top (elimination) and working down, safety professionals can achieve the highest level of protection for workers and compliance with regulations.
Difference Between Hazard and Risk: A Practical Guide for Safety Professionals
Forklift & Mobile Equipment Risk Assessment
Excavation & Trenching Risk Assessment
